I have a two-year-old. I want more than anything for the world that she raises a two-year-old in, to be as nice as the world that I was two in. I know that individual-level decisions are small chips in the fight against climate change. But this is what I can do directly.
Electric car for 99% of trips
We currently drive a reasonably new reasonably efficient internal combustion car. We don't drive a lot, but we do drive daily to and from the bus/daycare. The biggest impact we can have is relegating that car to days when we really need the extra range or extra capacity that we get with this car.
Replace old gas furnace with an electric heat pump
Our house has a 20-year-old 90% efficient furnace. If you lose 1% a year, then that furnace is running at 70% efficiency and burning natural gas. Moving to a heat pump would move us from fossil fuels to the very clean hydro-generated electricity in the northwest.
Solar panels on the house
I live in an area with very green power, mostly hydro. But we still buy some level of nuclear, coal and natural gas. If we can make our own solar, we can reduce the load on some of those fuel sources. We've got great south facing exposure on the roof. Putting solar panels on the roof helps make the entire energy mix more renewable.
Also, a plus, having solar panels probably makes my net electricity bill zero, which is fun. In an ideal world, I could run disconnected from the grid if/when the Cascadia megaquake happens; presuming the house is still standing.
Tankless electric water heater, electric stove
I have a newer natural gas water heater, so this is low on the list of things to replace. It's efficient and new but is one of the remaining sources of fossil fuels in the house.
My gas stovetop is going to be hardest personally for me, I love cooking on gas, it is a nice experience for cooking, heat is instantly there and instantly gone. But maybe if when we renovate the kitchen we switch to induction.
Since the unfortunate movie "The Innocence of Muslims" came to light the Muslim world has once again become enraged by the insult to their religion, their prophet and their history. Since then I've seen them labeled as barbarians and irrational. Their religion and culture have been classified as basically violent, and degraded, worthy of hatred and disdain. I've heard suggestions to cut all ties with the states where there are riots. People have suggested bombings and invasion. It all strikes me as silly and ignorant of our own Western history.
The key points in western history to be considered are the Thirty Years' War and the Peace of Westphalia. This conflict and the resulting peace are probably the defining events in what has turned into the European and American relationship between religion and the state as well as setting the basis for the modern nation state.
The war ravaged Europe for three decades over the ability of rulers to choose for their kingdom to be Catholic, Lutheran or Calvinist. The war involved every major and minor state in Europe as well as interventions by the Ottoman Empire in the Balkans. In those thirty years the population of German states were decreased by 25-30%, with some provinces loosing almost as much as 75% of their population.
All of that fighting, and bloodshed, disease and suffering ended in 1648 with the Peace of Westphalia which ultimately reaffirmed the 1555 treaty of Augsburg, which allowed sovereigns to choose the religion of their state and allow religious minorities to practice their faith without oppression. The peace is a peace of exhaustion. An admittance that no amount of bloodshed will make a person believe as you do, that perhaps it was just best to let people be and let God sort it out.
Most people will never think of the war or the peace when speaking of religious freedom and freedom of speech. But the American First Amendment has the underlying intent of the treaty baked in to it. Freedom to choose your religion and freedom to speak your mind. Most importantly the First Amendment extended that freedom to the individual level. That no man may call another man heretic with the force of law in his voice, is one of the most beautiful things about the American experience.
But that is the American experience which is an extension of another European idea and experience. The idea is so inherent to western society, that we forget that it is not a universal value. The Islamic world was not a party to the treaty. The treaty and its ideas are not part of their heritage.
Perhaps collectively they will get there, many parts of the Islamic world already are. Unfortunately at the same time Islamic fundamentalism is growing in some places as people strive to return to a "pure" Islam that created a caliphate st reaching from Spain to Pakistan. The conflicts between Sunni and Shia burn and fester as they have for a very long time.
All of which is bound and rolled in an Arab Spring which seeks to bring freedom from oppression and freedom of speech and association, but also allows them to express their objectionable views, and associate in ways that allow for violence to blossom where previously only repression grew.
None of this excuses violence and murder. None of this should preclude rational assessment that the actions of individuals do not represent the values of a country and culture as diverse as the United States. None of this excuses the perversion and sublimation of religious ideas to derail and influence a political process.
Democracy is hard, democracy is messy, countries are more likely to suffer from internal strife and external conflict during a transition to democracy then any other time.
But we won't make it any better by presupposing ideas from our history on to other cultures and expecting them to become a part of the fabric of a society based on our declaration alone.
Hopefully we can come to agreement on all of this sooner rather than later.
Update: This changed a while ago but I never updated this post to reflect it. ALARACT 239/2011 changed AR 670-1 to state that only shoes with a single toe pocket are allowed for wear in IPFUs. This is a decision based on the look of the shoe not the fact that they are minimalist shoes. If you are looking for alternatives there are thankfully a host of them out there. Altra Zero Drop Footwear, New Balance Minimus, Merrill Trail Glove, et all. To be honest, just about every major shoe company is now on board and has or is working on deploying a minimalist shoe.
-----Original Post------
As a member of the U.S. Army I love my Vibram Five Fingers but am frequently challenged about their legality in Uniform. Below is a list of resources to help defend your position when wearing your Vibram Five Fingers in your Improved Physical Fitness Uniform (IPFU).
a. Commanders may authorize the wear of commercial running shoes, calf-length or ankle-length, plain white socks with no logos, gloves, reflective belts or vests, long underwear, and other items appropriate to the weather conditions and type of activity.
Therefore it is ultimately up to your commander (at any level company and up) if you can or cannot wear Vibrams in Uniform. You should speak with your chain of command to ensure they will authorize your footwear choice. Be sure to talk to talk about the scientific research that promotes the health benefits of barefoot running. Be prepared to show them that they are in fact marketed as running shoes not aqua socks, house shoes, climbing shoes (although these are all things you can also do in your VFFs). Your biggest sticking point will probably be the toes, and the lack of foam under your heel.
I would highly recommend taking time to transition into to running in VFFs before you show up to organizational PT wearing them so that you can complete PT without having to slow down because your not used to running barefoot yet.
USF-I Uniform Policy
For those of you currently serving in Iraq USF-I has specific uniform policy that applies to all armed forces in Iraq. Thankfully the policy says nothing about running shoes at all.
Afghanistan
I've never served in Afghanistan so anyone who can point out or send me a copy of their uniform policy, I'll add it to this list.
Update: This changed a while ago but I never updated this post to reflect it. ALARACT 239/2011 changed AR 670-1 to state that only shoes with a single toe pocket are allowed for wear in IPFUs. This is a decision based on the look of the shoe not the fact that they are minimalist shoes. If you are looking for alternatives there are thankfully a host of them out there. Altra Zero Drop Footwear, New Balance Minimus, Merrill Trail Glove, et all. To be honest, just about every major shoe company is now on board and has or is working on deploying a minimalist shoe.
My name is Andrew Nortrup and I am one of your constituents. First let me say that I am incredibly pleased to have you as my Senator. I have heard your name in the news quite often in the recent weeks and I find that you continue to demonstrate the levelheaded moderation down to earth common sense that is the hallmark of our State. Please continue to do this and you will have my steadfast support when it comes time for you to run for re-election again.
I would like to spend a few minutes to discuss the health care debate. I know that you have worked intimately with it as a member of the finance committee. I also know that you have reserved final judgment on the bill to see what comes out of the joint Senate. I would like to make you aware of the things that I consider most pressing in health care reform for our country.
I agree with the President that the health care system in this country is in great need of reform. However, I disagree with the method of fixing the problem. The current proposals appear to be intent on extending insurance coverage to all Americans. It is a noble effort but I think that to fix it is to fix a symptom and not the cause of problem. The real culprit to our nations health care problems are the skyrocketing costs of health insurance, health care and medication are alarming.
I think that finding responsible methods of cost control should be our first objective. The single simplest manner to do this is through creating a uniform pricing standard for all payers in the health insurance system. The state of Maryland has had such a system in place for many years with great success, and I think that we should look to that as a model for the rest of the country.
A system where the country or each individual state sets a uniform cost for procedures and medications in their state would have many benefits. It would provide transparency to customers, allowing them to make like comparisons to their health insurance options. It allows doctors and hospitals to worry about providing medicine rather then fighting with the insurance company about the price of their procedures. Lastly it would allow insurance companies to reduce the overhead that the currently spend negotiating for prices, and instead reduce the prices they charge their customers. In contrast the current system where each insurance company and each health care provider negotiate individually on a case-by-case basis is wasteful and unjust. The amount of overhead that is spent by all actors in this system is wasteful, as each insurer must negotiate with every hospital every year for the price of every procedure. It also requires doctors, hospitals, and insurers to have large and complex billing departments to manage the collection of fees on different schedules for each insures or hospital that they work with.
Not only is the current system wasteful, it fails to provide beneficial or cost effective health care outcomes for the people it is intended to serve. There is no way that a system where two people receiving the same procedure in the same hospital from the same doctor pay two different prices is just. Worse yet the system skews high costs the uninsured and persons serviced by small health insurers who lack the bargaining power of the large health insurers in the region. (Redefining Health Care (2006), Michael E. Porter and Elizabeth Olmsted Teisberg p. 66). It creates a system that is anti-competitive by nature. The larger the insurers receive better prices causing the health care provider to raise the prices on small insurers to meet the bottom line.
Creating a national or state-by-state system where all health insurers and patients pay the same rate for all health care in their state is the best way to ensure that there is real competition in the marketplace. It will force insurers and providers to compete on the quality of their service and ability to provide economical pricing options to their clients.
Unfortunately I fear that that public option that was highly debated in the finance committee and is a part of the other four health reform bills currently being debated on the floors of congress will not actually create more competition and may restrict competition further. Because of the negotiated costs system that is currently in place in the health care industry, adding a new insurer with a set of fixed costs would drive insurers out of their small markets as the hospital's need to shift their costs somewhere to account for the lost revenue from a national plan with fixed rates.
Lastly, in the longer term we must also find ways to decouple health insurance from employers. This will enable the American worker in a way that they have not been enabled since WWII. They will be able to move freely from job to job without fear of not being hired because of their health. Secondly we must reform the payment system away from the fee-for-service model to a model that is based on treating illnesses as a whole. Such a system will encourage doctors and patients to get the treatments that are needed to cure them and not to get the tests that generate the most income.
In conclusion, please continue your steadfast work on behalf of the state of Maine, in order to ensure that the State and the country are on a healthy footing in our health care system. Do this by working to have a universal pricing system adopted as part of the health care reform process. I also look forward to the work that must be done in order to decouple health insurance from employment and to change the way that we charge for health to be based on your illness not on the procedures performed.
So the piracy problem off the coast of Somalia hit the news big several weeks ago (before Thanksgiving). I've been meaning to write this but haven't had time. I've read some crazy theories about what to do (cue Kristol who would have us invade a third country (Somalia) with the intent of eliminating bad people (Islamist Rebels and Pirates).
I'm no scholar of Naval strategy, but it seems to me that the Convoy strategy has worked before in defeating Pirates. The British did used it effectively in the Colonial South Pacific, the Americans did it during World War I and World War II against the Germans and the Japanese (WWII only).
With the U.S., British, Russian, Ukranian and Canadian Navies all patrolling those waters looking for Pirates it would seem convenient to simply escort the ships through the endangered waters. We can coordinate through the UN to handle scheduling. No one invades anyone. I'm sure that shipping insurance would even pay to underwrite some of the service in order to support money to help fund development in Somalia so that Piracy isn't your only economic choice.
Additionally we can do some trust building with the Russians, something we could use a whole lot of after the great Georgian debacle.
I know we are all tired of the election. However I ask you to consider, can the American economy to survive the end of the stimulus provided by this most expensive of campaigns ever. The damage to the advertising, t-shirt, and button industries could be crippling.
I say perpetual campaign for the economies sake.
Then again, I don't have a TV and don't have to live through the commercials.
John McCain in a second attempt to look like he is doing something proactive to help the economy has proposed to lower the capital gains taxes. He claims that his is a move targeted to help the middle class. Stating in an interview a McCain adviser stated:
“The market’s the focus,” a McCain adviser said. “You want to stop the fleeing.”
Now it seems to me that if you want to keep peoples money in the market removing capital gains taxes is a bad idea. Currently captial gains taxes provide a disinsentive to selling your stock assets. If you remove the disinsentive people now take less of a hit when the sell their stockes and transfer the money to something like precious metals, oil, a saving account or the shoe box under their matress.
Furthermore reducing capital gains taxes, for the most part, is not going to help the middle class. A reductiong in captial gains tax gives a disproportionate benefit to the wealthy. Persons in the top 3% of tax payers account 83% of the capital gains income. The Tax Policy Center says it best.
Fewer than one in seven individual income taxpayers reported taxable capital gains in 2006. Over half of taxpayers with gains had incomes below $75,000, but most capital gains were reported by very high income taxpayers. The 3 percent of returns with AGI over $200,000 reported 31 percent of AGI and 83 percent of capital gains; the 0.3 percent with AGI over $1,000,000 reported 15 percent of AGI and 61 percent of capital gains. Many more Americans accrue capital gains on corporate shares they hold within tax-deferred employer-sponsored retirement plans, but they do not pay capital gains tax on these gains.
Bottom line this policy might help some middle class people. But once agin, John McCain's tax policy disproportionately benefits the rich. Bellow is a graph, again from the Tax Policy Center (h/t: Obsidian Wings) comparing the estimated effect of the Tax Plans proposed by both canidates:
The entire episode goes on to prove once again somthing John McCain admited he does not understand the economy very well. Watch and see:
I must say that this video makes me breathe a sigh of relief.
It reminds me of the John McCain I remember from 2000 and the Gang of 14. A man of honor. If I had seen this John McCain througout the campaign I would have had a much harder decision this November.
I also think it is the first step in Senator McCain understanding that things do not look good in November and his best hope for a legacy that is not one of dirty personal attacks is to return to the Senate and do good bi-partisan work with a President Obama.
Even if he wins, good relations with Senator Obama are going to be crucial. He is the de-facto leader of the Democratic party. If he were to return to the Senate he will be the hands down favorite for the nomination in 2012 and a mandate spend the intervening years demonstrating good judgement and a bi-partisan ethic.
More than anything I'm glad that cooler heads may be prevailing before all of the bridges are burnt.
Alaska has no income tax. Alaska has no sales tax. Citizens of Alaska get paid yearlly from test state oil revenues. Alaska recieves the most pork per capita of any state in the union.
Gov. Palin supported the bridge to nowhere before the Federal Government pulled fuding for the project.
Research done in 2006 has confirmed the long-standing theory that there are 6.6 degrees of separation between you and any other person in the world. This means that there are only 6.6 steps between you and someone who has a communication disorder. iSeeIt is the innovative new way of expression for individuals struggling with Autism, loss of memory due to Alzheimer's, speech problems due to physical issues, or difficulties in the organizing of tasks or memory functions.
iSeeIt is a new idea in software – an image-based program for use on a Microsoft based PDA. iSeeIt is the simple and effective way to organize thoughts and enable communication through the user’s own personal images captured by digital camera and voice added through an easy record sequence. iSeeIt users include individuals of all ages and ability levels who struggle with sequencing and communication problems that inhibit their ability to reach out to the world around them. iSeeIt provides a custom tailored, team oriented approach that is completely unique to each specific user, enabling communication where none had been possible before.
One example of aniSeeIt success is a teenager with autism who had never been able to express her thoughts. Communication had always been merely repeating words that were spoken to her. iSeeIt elicited an amazing change – when viewing images of restaurants, this teenager spoke out “Chili’s, Call Daddy”. Her teachers were stunned – this was the first spontaneous phrase this teenager had ever said. How long had she known what to say, but had been unable to express it?
We invite you to visit our website (www.iSeeItSolutions.com) where you will be able to view an explanation and demonstration of this radically new approach to communication. Further, we would be grateful if you could help us spread the word by sending our website link to everyone within your email contact list or telling your friends.
Our family has developed and tested iSeeIt over the past six years to empower individuals, families and friends to overcome challenges and add their voices to the world. You may not know anyone with a communication disorder – but someone within your 6.6 degrees of separation could benefit greatly from this new idea.
There has been some confused comment on the statements by John McCain that he is just now learning to get online. The NYT reports:
He said, ruefully, that he had not mastered how to use the Internet and relied on his wife and aides like Mark Salter, a senior adviser, and Brooke Buchanan, his press secretary, to get him online to read newspapers (though he prefers reading those the old-fashioned way) and political Web sites and blogs.
“They go on for me,” he said. “I am learning to get online myself, and I will have that down fairly soon, getting on myself. I don’t expect to be a great communicator, I don’t expect to set up my own blog, but I am becoming computer literate to the point where I can get the information that I need.”
That was the snarky part. Here's a non-snarky question: what is hard about "getting online"? I assume he's not talking about having trouble setting up his cable modem, or something. I also assume he's talking about he web, and not about, say, having his computer update its clock automatically. What, exactly, do you have to do to get online? Well, you have to know which application is the one you click to surf the web, I guess. And it would help to have someone set up a few favorite sites for you, so that you could jump off from them, or at least read them when you felt like it. But, having done this myself for a few people who came of age long before PCs were invented, it's really not that hard. Did none of his kids, or his friends, or the people who work for him, offer? Does he perhaps not own a computer?
I understand the confusion on how an everyday person can get by in life without using a computer. But we'll be honest, Presidents and presidential candidates, and really leaders of any large organization are not everyday people. Not to say that they put their pants on differently but most of them are focused not on getting information (what most people do on the internet) but on processing information.
If you grew up with computers or had computers grow up with you it would be fairly easy to pick them up and use them yourself. However, if you were the powerful senior senator from the state of Arizona, with a busy schedule and an established routine, I can understand not making the time to learn how to ues them. He would already had a staff that used the internet to get him the information that he needs to continue doing his job of making decisions.
Now is it a problem that a possible President of the United States doesn't understand how the modern economy works? Yes.
Is understanding the effect of the blogsphere on traditional media and vice versa going to be an essential skill of politicians in the next 10 years? You can bet your presidential hopes on it.
Does it mean that he is missing serious opertunities in organizing and fundraising? Yes.
Those are all problems that concern me. The fact the Senator McCain doesn't carry a blackberry or read a blog, doesn't bother me.
Going through my blog feed stack today there was an interesting contrast on political campaign organization revolving around decentralization.
On the Republican side there is significant discussion about the shakeup in the McCain campaign who replaced their campaign manager Rick Davis with Steve Schmidt. Schmidt developed a decentralized strategy revolving around strong regional campaigns rather than a strong centralized campaign. To put it bluntly the strategy has failed. The McCain campaign lacks message consistency and focus, and has not been raising as much money as the Obama campaign (discounting the RNC funds). Additionally there are significant fractures in the campaign.
You can get the full background on Davis’s grand plans in Jason Zengerle’s wonderful “McCain-land” piece. The nickel version is that McCain-land has had at least two major factions – one loyal to Rick Davis, and one loyal to fellow long-time McCain devotee John Weaver (who was campaign manager before the shakeup in 2007). One point of contention is that Davis wanted to institute a decentralized campaign composed of various regional chairs. (In other words, the polar opposite of Bush-Cheney’s highly-unsuccessful and amateur 2004 operation, which was rigidly top-down. Yes, that’s sarcastic.) Long story short – Davis got the nod last year after Weaver departed and then proceeded to implement his decentralization plans.
The flip side of the coin is exposed by the Rolling Stone piece that highlights the internal workings of the core of the Obama campaign (h/t Hilzoy). The piece profiles the personalities of the top operatives you never hear about in the Obama campaign that make it run day in and day out. It is this core group that allows the campaign to run a vast, decentralized grass roots campaign. They are the source of information upon which the grass roots can feed and energize. Most notably however they are unified, tight liped and mostly anonymous. As Rolling Stone puts it:
It's also remarkably disciplined: Obama's top advisers outmaneuvered Hillary Clinton's organization with no leaks, no nasty infighting and virtually no public credit for their efforts. By all rights, Plouffe and the other chief architects of Obama's machine should be household names on par with James Carville and Karl Rove. And yet, with the exception of chief strategist David Axelrod, who has emerged as an affably low-key spokesman for the campaign, Obama's brain trust works in near anonymity from the campaign's headquarters on the 11th floor of a smoked-glass skyscraper two blocks south of the Chicago River.
That obscurity is by design. Members of Obama's inner circle are largely unknown to the public because the second rule of the campaign is: All credit accrues to Obama. The first rule? Don't talk about Team Obama. As senior adviser Valerie Jarrett puts it, "We aim for you to not know about the inner workings of the campaign because there's not much to know other than: It works."
These are the people who do 90% of the work to keep the campaign running but people perceive that the campaign is run by thousands of volunteers. This is not uncommon, Wikipedia and Digg have similar phenomenon highlighted by Slate's Chris Wilson.
Social-media sites like Wikipedia and Digg are celebrated as shining examples of Web democracy, places built by millions of Web users who all act as writers, editors, and voters. In reality, a small number of people are running the show. According to researchers in Palo Alto, 1 percent of Wikipedia users are responsible for about half of the site's edits. The site also deploys bots—supervised by a special caste of devoted users—that help standardize format, prevent vandalism, and root out folks who flood the site with obscenities. This is not the wisdom of the crowd. This is the wisdom of the chaperones.
So why did Obama succeed at decentralizing his campaign and creating the first 50 state general election strategy seen in recent history, while the McCain campaign is struggling to find a message that doesn't cause people to yawn?
Both campaigns tried to do the same thing, create grassroots movement in order capture the individual energy of your supporters without having to spend money on it. Being told how wonderful a canidate is by the people you know and love is far more convincing then all of the campaign advertising in the world as demonstrated by the Obama campaign's attempts to defeat the viral smear campaign about him that was profiled by the Washington Post on Monday.
I think the biggest reason that the Obama campaign was able to do this and Republicans have been largely troubled by it is that that Obama started with a message built a group to shape the message then decentralized. The Republicans decentralized then tried to develop different messages to meet the needs of each region. When they did so they failed to provide the kindling that lights the fire of a movement.
Additionally the Obama message is broad enough to tap into many different desires in people and also provides them latitude to create their own sub messages. "Hope" is a huge message, it is an ideological decedent of Regan's "Morning in America" but still accommodates this:
In contrast it is much harder to get people to excited about messages like these.
Lower corperate taxes
Lets stay in Iraq forever
The terrorists want to kill us all
I've pissed off just about every Democrat and Republican in the past eight years and this is a sign of my bi-partisanship
Which are in fact not messages they are policy proposals. Policy proposals are important and in a ideal world you would win political campaigns on the merits of your policy. But it is not an ideal world people are more likely to vote for you as much because they trust you to do the right thing in the situation that you can't plan for.
The average person does not have the time to dig in to the statistics and economics that go into determining the optimal marginal tax rate. Wonk is defined in Wikitonary as "An overly studious or hard-working person; A persnickety person, overly focuses on details; A nerd or an expert" most people make fun of that guy, they are not him.
Obama still has policy proposals on health care and tax policy. He also has a wonkish legislative history including creating a search enabled database for earmarks and government contracts, securing loose nukes in former Soviet Republics, tape recording interrogations in capital crimes (Illinois), but you don't see him leading with these proposals. Instead you hook on the message "Change". Once you have people convinced that you both want to change, talking about how to change is much easier.
In conclusion decentralization is not something that happens easily or you can do on the cheap. It requires three things:
A broad message to shape the movement and inspire people to volunteer to support it
A dedicated group of people to shape and direct the movement at the macro level
The willingness to let people go and do their own thing
The Obama campaign seems to have done all three and it has paid off. The McCain campaign tried the third alone, and it didn't happen. Now in July before a November election they must try to recreate their organization. Sometimes life sucks.
General Wesley Clark stepped on a land mine Sunday when he got on TV and questioned if McCain's experience in Vietnam really quallified him to be President. The statement quickly devolved from a reasonable question about what constitutes the requisate experience to be Commander and Chief to a process story about someone questioning McCain's patriotism and military record.
For the record I have the greatest respect for Senator McCain's long and valiant service to this country. There is no question in my mind of his valor and dedication to his country. There were ample chances for him to forgoe pain and suffering to come home from Vietnam. The fact that he did not is a testament to his patriotism.
However I think that GEN Clark has a point. To the best of my knowledge McCain was not a leader (in the formal command sense) while acting as a fighter pilot. While in prison he would have had some degree of leadership because of his rank, but it certainly was not command.
More than anything his military service while in the prison camp was a study in perseverance. The question that matters is, does that experience support his claims of supperior knowledge and leadership in war time. It is a question that each individual will have to answer for themself before the election. I'm personally not sold on it, and my problems with his policy positions doesn't help.
I think the second thing to remember on this set of remarks is that there is a process story. GEN Clark's name has been floated more than once as a good choice for V.P. He had one of the stronger runs for the Democratic nomination in 2004, even managed to win a few states before John Kerry locked up the nomination. Clark was also a Clinton supporter. To put the icing on the cake he was the Commander of NATO during the invation of Bosnia.
If he was trying to audition for the job this is certainly one way to do it. He has sufficent military command experience to question John McCain's executive experieince, and it shows him as the effective attack surrogate that the VP must now be after eight years of Mr. Cheney.
At the end of the day it the entire incident is was a good question fouled up by a mixed set of process interactions.
My friend Joe put up a blurb on a site called wordle that creates word clouds from text. Word clouds are a collection of the common words in a set of words, with size and intensity derived from their frequency in the set.
I thought it would be cool to see what the contents of this blog look like so I played with some code (see below) and came up with this:
To do this I used C#, the Google Data API for Blogger and the following code to rip out the contents of the blog, strip the HTML tags (very necessary). I output the contents to a form field and then copied it into wordle.
FeedQuery fq = new FeedQuery(); fq.Uri = new Uri("http://www.blogger.com/feeds/[blog id here]/posts/default"); Service service = new Service(); AtomFeed f = service.Query(fq);
I'm catching up on my reading on this fine Satruday afternoon. There was a post that has a YouTube clip of Bruce Springsteen's tribute to Tim Russert at his funeral. Before he started playing he said something that I think touches on one of the reasons I love my job.
"He belived in the joyful duty of the honesty of service"
Two points for the Boss, coming through on an artists dream of capturing something profound.
I had a discussion with a friend a couple weeks ago about globalization and how the world and the United States moves forward to a state where labor is equally valued around the world in order to create more fair trade.
I've thought about it quite a bit and I think that the recent catastrophic earthquake in China is a good example of how the system moves forward. To be clear I think that the disaster and all of its immediate results are terrible. However, I think that in the long term there may be beneficial side effects for China and for the world in general.
One of the tragedies that received the most press coverage during the disaster was the collapse of several schools. The schools were aparently not designed or constructed strong enough to resist the earth quake. As a result many young lives were lost and there was much public anger. The Chinese government has attempted to control and quiet this anger as much as possible. However in the long run they are going to have to be sure that the same problem does not occur again.
In order to do this they must train and employ more skilled and honest architects, contractors, building inspectors, seismologists and number of other professions. Because we do live in a global market place, especially in the skilled labor market, the Chinese government will have to increase what they pay these craftsman.
Ultimately this will increase the level of skill and level of pay across the Chinese market place because if you don't want you children to attend an unstable school would you want to work in an unstable factory? I think not.
In the long run the change will be good for China, who will have more skilled craftsman and professionals. It will also benefit the United States and the World because the cost of doing business will begin to level out between China and the United States, creating a more fair labor market place.
In that arena countries must compete on the merits of their skills and comparative advantages. Innovation again becomes an important element to being the best producer. I'll put my money on the United States just about any day in that competition.
The recent events in Lebanon are a perfect example of the Iranian method of revolution. They follow a pretty consistent set of steps.
Select or create one or many proxy organization whom they share a common enemy or ideology.
Train and resource the proxy.
Have the proxy start a fight, large enough to be significant, but short of an all out revolution.
Continue the fight until there is a moderate breakdown of order.
Appear magnanimous by ending the conflict in the name of saving the country or people. As part of the settlement demand a larger share of the power.
Once the fight is over fill the void in civil services left by the breakdown of order with their own services. This includes setting up hospitals, schools, housing assistance, collecting taxes, utilities.
Use these services as a platform for building popular support for military activities or democratic support.
Repeat steps 1 though 6 as often as needed to gain regional control and influence.
This is the same play book they followed in Lebanon when they picked a fight with Israel, and what they are doing right now, it also worked to gain control of Gaza.
The problem is not just limited to Lebanon, Israel and Palestine. They have been backing all of the prominent Iraqi political parties for years. Members of the current Iraqi government continue to draw a pension from Iran from their time serving as proxies against Saddam, while they complain about Iranian funding for al'Sadr.
You have to give them credit. It is a very effective strategy so long as they don't get themselves into to large of a fight. Even large fights are easy to disengage with when everyone just puts down their gun and takes off a ski mask.
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton warned Tehran on Tuesday that if she were president, the United States could "totally obliterate" Iran in retaliation for a nuclear strike against Israel.
On the day of a crucial vote in her nomination battle against fellow Democrat Barack Obama, the New York senator said she wanted to make clear to Tehran what she was prepared to do as president in hopes that this warning would deter any Iranian nuclear attack against the Jewish state.
"I want the Iranians to know that if I'm the president, we will attack Iran (if it attacks Israel)," Clinton said in an interview on ABC's "Good Morning America."
"In the next 10 years, during which they might foolishly consider launching an attack on Israel, we would be able to totally obliterate them," she said.
"That's a terrible thing to say but those people who run Iran need to understand that because that perhaps will deter them from doing something that would be reckless, foolish and tragic," Clinton said.
I've previoustly posted about the foolishness of attacking Iran, here. And why I don't think that it would be reasonable or necessary, here. So this one hits me like a brick in the face from the person who claimed she has the experience and knowlege to handle the "3 AM Phone call" (I'll not link to this because I don't want to promte the original and the array of satire is to large).
Regardless, certain presidential canidates don't appear to be reading my humble postings, so I'll instead burden all of you with a couple of quick facts that might show, once again, why the military is not likely the solution to the Iranian problem.
Iran
Iraq
Difference
Population
65,397,521
27,499,638
37,897,883 more people in Iran
Square KM
1,648,000
437,072
Iran is 1,210,928 Square KM larger
There are more statistics but I think my point is fairly evident. If you think Iraq has been bad, imagine Iran with twice the people and about three times the land area.
Additionally we can feel fairly confident in the statements of former chairman of the joint chiefs Colin Powell when he says that we cannot sustain troop levels in Iraq.
The last argument to make is that Mrs. Clinton is not proposing to invade Iran, only to bomb it or use nuclear weapons. I'll leave the nuclear threat alone. I think there are a myrad or reasons not to. On the conventional side, bombing of Serbia was less than effective (Chapter 16 of "The Use of Force" by Art, Robert J and Waltz, Kenneth N.). Plus the Iranians have learned from Iraq's experience with building nuclear weapons. They have spread their facilities out and placed them deep underground. In all likelyhood the United States would stand a limited chance of dislodging the Iraq.
So in summary: bombing Iran = unlikely to work invading Iran = even less likely to work 5 years of threatening iran = no results yet evidence that "obliterating Iran" won't work = pretty conclusive
I felt a great disturbence in the force when I read this article at Balkanization today. I really hope I'm not the only person who is disturbed by the fact that all of a sudden we are again hinting about invading Iran. I was worried this would happen when it was announced that Adm. Fallon was leaving CENTCOM. Even then I told myself, "Surely the NIEA report will stay their hand." Nope, "Special Groups" have emmerged from obscurity to be the primary problem in Iraq.
It leaves me with one question that I would like you to ask yourself, your Senetors, your House Representatives, friends, neighbors, colleages, random strangers on the street and childern.
If special groups are a problem in Iraq. What sort of problem would they be if they were fully employed in Iraq, Iran, Israel, Palestine, Syria, and Lebenon?
I've posted previously that Iran has on numerous occasions responded to international pressure to change their actions. This is because the leaders of the Iranian state are generally interested in remaining in power. They understand that as part of the international system there are things that they are lines they cannot cross and expect to stay in power.
However, if we invade or intervean in Iran I think it is exreamly likely the controlers of the special groups will want to show the West exactly how much trouble they can cause if they show less restraint.
Since the end of the Iran/Iraq war in 1989 Iran has chosen to fight most of its battles by proxy. Hezbolah, the Mhedi Army, Syria's control of Lebenon and countless others are the mechanism that the Iranians use to advance their ideology around the world. They have been developing the network for almost two decades. If the United States or any state removes their motivations for caution we are going to find out how exactly how far the network reaches and what resources they have at their disposal.
Likely scenarios:
Unrestrainted rocket and suicide attacks on Israel.
An end to al-Sadr's ceasefire.
Moderate leaders of the lebanease government being killed wholesale.
So ask yourself in an optamistic manner, if its bad now, how much worse could it get?
I'm very disturbed by this set of comments by Gen. Machael Hayden, the director of the CIA, on Meet the Press last Sunday.
MR. RUSSERT: This is an article, Friday's paper: "[Iraqi] Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki ... decided to launch the offensive without consulting his U.S. allies, according to administration officials. With little U.S. presence in the south, and British forces in Basra confined to an air base outside the city, one administration official said that, `we can't quite decipher' what is going on. It's a question, he said, of `who's got the best conspiracy' theory about why Maliki decided to act now." The United States was not informed by the Iraqis that we--he was going to do this?
GEN. HAYDEN: I, I don't know what on--what went on on the ground in Baghdad prior to the operation. I do know that this was a decision of the Iraqi government by the prime minister and personally by the prime minister, and that he's relying on Iraqi forces, by and large, to take this action.
MR. RUSSERT: Were you aware of it?
GEN. HAYDEN: I was--in terms of being prebriefed or, or having, you know, the, the normal planning process in which you build up to this days or weeks ahead of time, no. No, I was not.
MR. RUSSERT: You didn't know it was going to happen?
GEN. HAYDEN: No more so than Dave Petraeus or Ambassador Crocker did.
I've written previously on the need to support the Iraqi governments efforts to become the sovereign in their country by gaining a monopoly on violence in their country. I still support that and I think that so long as we have military assets there we should employ them to that end.
However I think we need to draw a clear that the sudden and unannounced efforts like what has occurred in Basra for the past two weeks are not acceptable. It is unacceptable because it was a fight that the Iraqi government should have known that they could not win without the assistance of American forces, including close air support and ground troops. Iraqi troops are yet to go into a fight that they haven't needed American support to function effectively.
We need to make it clear to the Iraqis that we are there to help but they cannot begin operations that are going to put American lives at risk without consulting us first. To do so is an abuse of our friendship and good will.
Regardless of all of this, American support is not a blank check. If Iraq wants our help they need to keep us in the loop.
======== One last important note. Everything I write here are my own opinions gathered from what I read in publicly available news articles. In no way are the opinions expressed official government positions.